Learning objectives
- Order tests that will change management, and anticipate false positives.
- Explain reference intervals and when "optimal" ranges are evidence-based.
- Judge specialty tests by their evidence before ordering.
Ordering with purpose
Before ordering, ask: will this result change what I do? If not, it adds cost, worry and follow-up testing.
- Panels multiply false positives. Reference intervals cover 95% of healthy people, so each test flags about 1 in 20 healthy patients. With 20 independent tests, the chance of at least one "abnormal" result is about 64%.
- Pretest probability matters. A positive result in a low-risk patient is more likely to be a false positive.
- Cost is part of the decision. Many specialty tests are self-pay. Tell patients the cost and what the result could change.
Choosing Wisely examples that apply here: don't screen healthy adults for vitamin D deficiency, don't order reverse T3 routinely, and don't use IgG testing to diagnose food allergy or intolerance.
Reference vs. optimal ranges
A reference interval is the middle 95% of results from a reference population. It describes what is common, not always what is healthy.
- Some "optimal" targets are evidence-based: LDL goals by cardiovascular risk, A1c targets, ferritin of 75 ng/mL or higher for restless legs, and 25-hydroxyvitamin D of 20 ng/mL or higher for bone health (Institute of Medicine).
- Many are not. Narrow "functional ranges" for TSH, fasting insulin or other markers often lack outcome data. Treating to them can cause harm, such as overtreating thyroid disease.
- Results vary. Biological variation, lab methods, fasting, time of day (testosterone and cortisol), recent exercise, and biotin all change results. Repeat a surprising value before acting.
- Trends beat single values. A rising A1c within the normal range tells you more than one result.
Specialty tests: what holds up
Specialty labs (including those ordered through ordering platforms) range from well validated to unproven. A quick guide:
| Test | Evidence | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Fecal calprotectin | Strong | Separating IBS from inflammatory bowel disease |
| ApoB and Lp(a) | Strong | Cardiovascular risk |
| Coronary artery calcium | Strong | Statin decisions in borderline or intermediate risk |
| hs-CRP | Moderate | Cardiovascular risk enhancer |
| Glucose or lactulose breath test | Moderate, with limits | Suspected SIBO |
| Fasting insulin and HOMA-IR | Limited standardization | Tracking insulin resistance over time |
| Dried urine hormone panels | Limited validation | Not a substitute for serum testing; not needed to dose menopause hormone therapy |
| Organic acids | Limited | Rare inherited metabolic disorders (specialist use) |
| Comprehensive stool microbiome | Not validated for treatment decisions | Not recommended in routine care |
| IgG food sensitivity | Not valid | Not recommended |
| Salivary cortisol "adrenal fatigue" panel | Not valid | Not recommended (late-night salivary cortisol for Cushing's is valid) |
| Urine mycotoxins, provoked urine metals | Not valid | Not recommended |
| MTHFR genotype | Not useful | ACMG recommends against testing for thrombophilia or pregnancy loss |
When a patient brings outside results, thank them, explain what the test can and can't show, and refocus on findings that change care.
Clinical pearls
- Ask "What will I do differently with this result?" before ordering.
- Repeat a surprising result before you treat it.
- Most cardiometabolic risk can be estimated from a standard lipid panel, A1c, blood pressure, plus a one-time Lp(a).
Red flags: refer or work up first
- Critical values (very high potassium, very low sodium, very high calcium, severe anemia): act the same day.
- A test result that doesn't fit the patient: consider lab error, interference (biotin) or specimen problems.
- Incidental findings: follow evidence-based guidance and avoid cascades of further testing.
Case
A patient brings a $400 panel showing "high" IgG to eggs, dairy and wheat, a "low" salivary cortisol pattern, and an MTHFR variant. They've cut out eggs, dairy and wheat and feel worse.
Show discussion
Explain that IgG reflects exposure, not intolerance; the salivary panel isn't validated for adrenal fatigue; and MTHFR variants are common and don't change care. Help them reintroduce foods one at a time. If their symptoms suggest celiac disease, test once they are eating wheat again, since the test needs gluten exposure. Then run a focused evaluation of the symptoms that brought them in.
- Choosing Wisely (ABIM Foundation): recommendations from the Endocrine Society, AAAAI, and American Society for Clinical Pathology.
- Institute of Medicine. Dietary Reference Intakes for Calcium and Vitamin D. 2011.
- Hickey SE, et al. ACMG Practice Guideline: lack of evidence for MTHFR polymorphism testing. Genet Med. 2013; reaffirmed 2020.
- Grundy SM, et al. 2018 AHA/ACC Guideline on the Management of Blood Cholesterol. Circulation. 2019.
- Lacy BE, et al. ACG Clinical Guideline: Management of Irritable Bowel Syndrome. Am J Gastroenterol. 2021.
- American College of Medical Toxicology. Position statement on post-chelator challenge urinary metal testing. 2010.
Understanding your labs
- "Normal" ranges cover most healthy people. A result slightly outside the range is often fine, and we may repeat it.
- More tests aren't always better. Each extra test raises the chance of a false alarm.
- Before blood work: ask if you need to fast, stop biotin for 2 days, and tell us about supplements.
- Some tests sold online aren't reliable, such as IgG food sensitivity tests. Ask us before paying for one.
Good questions to ask about any test: What will this show? Will it change my treatment? What does it cost?
General education for licensed clinicians and the public. Not medical advice, and not a substitute for clinical judgment, current guidelines, or a visit with a licensed provider. Product names are examples, not endorsements. Drug doses, coding rules and guidance change; check current labeling, payer rules and guidelines before acting. Book a visit with Empowered Health.
