Root Cause Clinical Course · Module 10 of 10 · 3 lessons · 34 min

Lab selection and interpretation

Learning objectives

  • Order tests that will change management, and anticipate false positives.
  • Explain reference intervals and when "optimal" ranges are evidence-based.
  • Judge specialty tests by their evidence before ordering.
Lesson 1 of 3

Ordering with purpose

Before ordering, ask: will this result change what I do? If not, it adds cost, worry and follow-up testing.

  • Panels multiply false positives. Reference intervals cover 95% of healthy people, so each test flags about 1 in 20 healthy patients. With 20 independent tests, the chance of at least one "abnormal" result is about 64%.
  • Pretest probability matters. A positive result in a low-risk patient is more likely to be a false positive.
  • Cost is part of the decision. Many specialty tests are self-pay. Tell patients the cost and what the result could change.

Choosing Wisely examples that apply here: don't screen healthy adults for vitamin D deficiency, don't order reverse T3 routinely, and don't use IgG testing to diagnose food allergy or intolerance.

Lesson 2 of 3

Reference vs. optimal ranges

A reference interval is the middle 95% of results from a reference population. It describes what is common, not always what is healthy.

  • Some "optimal" targets are evidence-based: LDL goals by cardiovascular risk, A1c targets, ferritin of 75 ng/mL or higher for restless legs, and 25-hydroxyvitamin D of 20 ng/mL or higher for bone health (Institute of Medicine).
  • Many are not. Narrow "functional ranges" for TSH, fasting insulin or other markers often lack outcome data. Treating to them can cause harm, such as overtreating thyroid disease.
  • Results vary. Biological variation, lab methods, fasting, time of day (testosterone and cortisol), recent exercise, and biotin all change results. Repeat a surprising value before acting.
  • Trends beat single values. A rising A1c within the normal range tells you more than one result.
Lesson 3 of 3

Specialty tests: what holds up

Specialty labs (including those ordered through ordering platforms) range from well validated to unproven. A quick guide:

TestEvidenceUse it for
Fecal calprotectinStrongSeparating IBS from inflammatory bowel disease
ApoB and Lp(a)StrongCardiovascular risk
Coronary artery calciumStrongStatin decisions in borderline or intermediate risk
hs-CRPModerateCardiovascular risk enhancer
Glucose or lactulose breath testModerate, with limitsSuspected SIBO
Fasting insulin and HOMA-IRLimited standardizationTracking insulin resistance over time
Dried urine hormone panelsLimited validationNot a substitute for serum testing; not needed to dose menopause hormone therapy
Organic acidsLimitedRare inherited metabolic disorders (specialist use)
Comprehensive stool microbiomeNot validated for treatment decisionsNot recommended in routine care
IgG food sensitivityNot validNot recommended
Salivary cortisol "adrenal fatigue" panelNot validNot recommended (late-night salivary cortisol for Cushing's is valid)
Urine mycotoxins, provoked urine metalsNot validNot recommended
MTHFR genotypeNot usefulACMG recommends against testing for thrombophilia or pregnancy loss

When a patient brings outside results, thank them, explain what the test can and can't show, and refocus on findings that change care.

Clinical pearls

  • Ask "What will I do differently with this result?" before ordering.
  • Repeat a surprising result before you treat it.
  • Most cardiometabolic risk can be estimated from a standard lipid panel, A1c, blood pressure, plus a one-time Lp(a).

Red flags: refer or work up first

  • Critical values (very high potassium, very low sodium, very high calcium, severe anemia): act the same day.
  • A test result that doesn't fit the patient: consider lab error, interference (biotin) or specimen problems.
  • Incidental findings: follow evidence-based guidance and avoid cascades of further testing.

Case

A patient brings a $400 panel showing "high" IgG to eggs, dairy and wheat, a "low" salivary cortisol pattern, and an MTHFR variant. They've cut out eggs, dairy and wheat and feel worse.

Show discussion

Explain that IgG reflects exposure, not intolerance; the salivary panel isn't validated for adrenal fatigue; and MTHFR variants are common and don't change care. Help them reintroduce foods one at a time. If their symptoms suggest celiac disease, test once they are eating wheat again, since the test needs gluten exposure. Then run a focused evaluation of the symptoms that brought them in.

Question 1: If you order 20 independent tests on a healthy person, the chance of at least one abnormal result is about:

Question 2: Which specialty test is well validated?

References
  • Choosing Wisely (ABIM Foundation): recommendations from the Endocrine Society, AAAAI, and American Society for Clinical Pathology.
  • Institute of Medicine. Dietary Reference Intakes for Calcium and Vitamin D. 2011.
  • Hickey SE, et al. ACMG Practice Guideline: lack of evidence for MTHFR polymorphism testing. Genet Med. 2013; reaffirmed 2020.
  • Grundy SM, et al. 2018 AHA/ACC Guideline on the Management of Blood Cholesterol. Circulation. 2019.
  • Lacy BE, et al. ACG Clinical Guideline: Management of Irritable Bowel Syndrome. Am J Gastroenterol. 2021.
  • American College of Medical Toxicology. Position statement on post-chelator challenge urinary metal testing. 2010.
Patient handout · plain language

Understanding your labs

  • "Normal" ranges cover most healthy people. A result slightly outside the range is often fine, and we may repeat it.
  • More tests aren't always better. Each extra test raises the chance of a false alarm.
  • Before blood work: ask if you need to fast, stop biotin for 2 days, and tell us about supplements.
  • Some tests sold online aren't reliable, such as IgG food sensitivity tests. Ask us before paying for one.

Good questions to ask about any test: What will this show? Will it change my treatment? What does it cost?

General education for licensed clinicians and the public. Not medical advice, and not a substitute for clinical judgment, current guidelines, or a visit with a licensed provider. Product names are examples, not endorsements. Drug doses, coding rules and guidance change; check current labeling, payer rules and guidelines before acting. Book a visit with Empowered Health.